Tensions Flare in Scottish Parliament Over Salmon Farming Debate
A heated exchange took place in the Scottish Parliament during a discussion on the future of salmon farming, with Tory MSP Edward Mountain accusing Salmon Scotland chief executive Tavish Scott of verbally attacking him.
The exchange occurred as the committee reviewed a report on the salmon industry’s progress. Mountain questioned Scott about the transparency of the industry and the right for stakeholders to challenge salmon farming practices.
He noted that Scott had been “aggressive” toward those who questioned the industry and its environmental impact.
Scott responded forcefully, defending the industry and the 12,000 people employed within it. He argued that anti-salmon farming groups aim to “put us all out of a job,” adding that the attacks against the sector extend beyond the industry and could eventually target other forms of farming, including cattle and sheep.
“I absolutely accept that stakeholders have the right to say what they like,” said Scott, “but I also have the right to defend the industry and call out the nonsense we’re subjected to every day.”
Mountain pressed further, referencing a private meeting in which Scott allegedly told him, “The issue is your attitude,” and claimed that the Salmon Scotland board was unhappy with Mountain’s stance and considering action unless he retracted his criticisms.
Scott denied knowledge of any private discussion being recorded, and the committee convenor intervened, urging both parties to refocus on the industry’s progress rather than personal disputes.
During the session, Mowi CEO Ben Hadfield also addressed the underlying tensions between the salmon farming industry and salmon anglers. He acknowledged the friction, particularly between farming and wild fishing interests, but emphasized the need for “full transparency” and constructive dialogue. “We all agree that everyone has the right to criticize aquaculture, ask questions, and expect transparency,” Hadfield stated, while advocating for reducing tensions between the two sectors over time.
